We Tasted 9 Frozen Pie Crusts—Right here Are Our Favorites

Baking-heavy holidays like Thanksgiving will be overwhelming affairs: You’ve acquired to prepare dinner a show-stopping centerpiece like turkey or rib roast, prep all the edges, and—relying on the scale of your celebration—make a number of pies. Whereas many people aspire to make pie crust from scratch, typically you merely would not have the time or bandwidth, which is the place ready-made pie dough is available in. At the same time as an avid baker and food skilled who retains do-it-yourself pie dough in my freezer, I attain for a frozen crust occasionally. With loads of store-bought choices to select from, there’s no have to stress about making your individual dough from scratch whenever you’ve acquired a number of different issues in your thoughts and in your oven. However even if you happen to aren’t making a do-it-yourself pie crust, you wish to be certain the crust you’re utilizing is sturdy sufficient to carry your pie filling and tastes nice. 

To search out out which frozen pie doughs and shells are price shopping for, we pulled collectively 9 totally different pie crusts you’re more likely to discover in your native grocery store, baked and stuffed them with pumpkin pie filling (utilizing the identical pie filling for every one), and sampled them with out understanding which crust was which. Our assessments included pre-rolled dough that it’s a must to thaw and form into your individual pie pan, in addition to uncooked shells pre-shaped and offered inside a tin. After tasting our means by 9 freshly made pies, we then saved every for a day within the fridge to see how properly they held up. After this barely queasy-making however general very enjoyable two-day pie-eating contest, we tabulated the outcomes and topped an general winner we’d be pleased to ask to our personal Thanksgiving celebrations, in addition to just a few different worthy contenders. 

The Standards

Pie crust needs to be crisp and flaky, with a pleasing buttery taste. It ought to have a slight trace of salt however not be overly salty, nor ought to or not it’s overly candy. It needs to be simply tender sufficient to present means when bitten into, however not so smooth that it crumbles on the slightest contact. One of the best pie crusts must also be sturdy sufficient to resist the load and moisture of any pie filling, be it custard, fruit, or syrupy nuts. In a perfect world, pie crust needs to be so scrumptious that you simply’d wish to nibble away on the edges of the pie whenever you assume no person is wanting.

Total Winner: Dealer Joe’s Pie Crusts

Our tasters loved each the flavour and texture of Dealer Joe’s pie crust, which is discovered within the freezer part as a pre-rolled dough that you simply press right into a pan earlier than baking. Our affiliate editorial director, Megan O. Steintrager, thought it was “gentle and buttery,” whereas Doan Nguyen, photograph editor at Meals and Wine—with whom we share workplace house in NYC—described its taste as having “a pleasant steadiness with salt and butter.” The crust was flaky and had good structural integrity; considered one of our tasters known as it a “workhorse crust.” It additionally held up properly the following day, making it pre-rolled dough to achieve for if you happen to plan on touring along with your pie or getting ready it a day prematurely. At simply $4.49, this crust is each scrumptious and inexpensive, and one we would gladly use for our personal pies.

Runners Up

The Greatest Handy Pie Crust: Wholly Healthful Natural Conventional 9” Pie Shells

“Stable, crumbly, however not structurally inconsistent,” our Meals and Wine colleague Dylan Garret wrote of this pie shell. “Pie deal with works properly as a pie deal with and didn’t break,” he wrote, referring to how you can choose up a slice by the sting of the crust with out it breaking and sending your pie onto the ground. Our affiliate visuals director, Amanda Suarez, thought this dough tasted “nice,” and others thought it was buttery, subtly candy, and scrumptious sufficient to eat by itself. This dough comprises simply 5 substances—natural wheat flour, natural palm fruit shortening, water, natural cane sugar, and sea salt—making it one of many crusts with the fewest substances used if that is a promoting level for you. Curiously, there may be zero butter, even supposing a couple of taster made notes of its buttery taste. 

Like our general winner, this crust held up properly the following day, and although barely softened, nonetheless maintained its form and chunk. As a result of this can be a pre-shaped pie shell, there’s zero crimping or shaping concerned, making it a handy possibility to achieve for if you happen to’re in a pinch however nonetheless need a flaky, tasty dough.

An Inexpensive however Scrumptious Choice: Boston Baking Homestyle 9-Inch Pie Shells

This frozen pie shell was tender and crumbly; this was Megan’s favourite—she thought it was buttery, albeit “ever so barely synthetic tasting.” Equally, Amanda described this as “good and buttery,” noting that it “looks like what a pie crust is.” Some tasters, nonetheless, thought it was barely sandy and dry. With simply 5 substances, Boston Baking’s pie shells (together with Wholly Healthful’s pie shells) had the shortest ingredient listing of all of the doughs we sampled, and contained simply flour, butter, water, sugar, and salt. (Observe to Megan: Nothing synthetic right here, so we’re not positive what you have been tasting!) Although this pie crust was barely softer the following day, it nonetheless held up fairly properly. At $4.79, Boston Baking is a scrumptious pie shell that’s additionally budget-friendly.

The Flakiest Pie Dough: Wholly Healthful Natural Conventional Pie Dough

Each single taster famous how flaky Wholly Healthful’s pre-rolled dough was. Megan discovered it “flaky to the purpose of being crumbly,” whereas Amanda thought it was a bit too flaky for her liking. But when a crisp pie crust with loads of layers is what you’re after, that is your greatest wager. Although some tasters thought this dough had a barely bitter taste, others thought it was balanced and buttery. 

Wholly Healthful’s totally formed and ready-to-bake frozen pie shells coated above have simply 5 substances; this dough, which is formed and prepared so that you can pop into your individual pan, has seven: wheat flour, palm fruit shortening, water, cane syrup, salt, cane sugar, and guar gum. As soon as once more, not a single ounce of butter in sight. Resulting from its excessive flakiness, this crust didn’t maintain up properly when saved with filling inside, as an alternative crumbling simply when pressed the following day. For those who plan on utilizing this pre-rolled dough, we suggest having fun with your pie the day it’s made—until a soggy backside is what you’re after. At $8.69, this was the most costly pie dough we sampled.

The Contenders

• Dealer Joe’s Pie Crusts $4.49
• Wholly Healthful Natural Conventional 9” Pie Shells $7.99
• Wholly Healthful Natural Conventional Pie Dough $8.69
• Boston Baking Homestyle Pie Shells $4.79
• Cease & Store Pie Crust Deep Dish 9-Inch $4.99
• Marie Callender’s Pastry Pie Shells $6.39
• 365 by Entire Meals Frozen Pie Dough $5.99
• Pillsbury Refrigerated Pie Crust $5.29
• Pillsbury Frozen Pie Crust, Deep Dish, Two 9-Inch $5.99

In Conclusion

Whereas our winners might go for do-it-yourself—sure, by baker!—among the crusts we tasted had stale and even rancid notes, with some that have been both too powerful, crispy, and borderline chewy. Total, our favourite pie crusts have been those who have been in a position to strike a steadiness between taste and texture: They have been all scrumptious, each crisp and tender, and contained seven substances or fewer. Although our tasters had a desire for crusts with what they perceived as a buttery taste, three out of our 4 prime picks contained shortening as an alternative of butter, and our winner had each butter and shortening. Not like most of the different pie crusts we tasted, our winners didn’t include preservatives, meals coloring, soybean oil, or dough conditioners. In different phrases: Our favourite pie crusts all contained substances that we’d doubtless attain for in our personal houses when getting ready dough.

Our Testing Methodology

All style assessments are carried out with manufacturers fully hidden and with out dialogue. Tasters style samples in random order. For instance, taster A might style pattern 1 first, whereas taster B will style pattern 6 first. That is to forestall palate fatigue from unfairly giving anybody pattern a bonus. Tasters are requested to fill our tasting sheets rating the samples for numerous standards. All information is tabulated and outcomes are calculated with no editorial enter with a view to give us probably the most neutral illustration of precise outcomes doable.