We Examined 12 Strategies to Craft a Fried Oreo Recipe That is Higher Than Any State Honest’s

This recipe is for individuals from New Jersey. For those who’re not from New Jersey, hold scrolling. 

For authorized functions, that’s a joke. With a view to perceive the enjoyment and significance of a fried Oreo, you actually simply must be an individual who’s been to a theme park, a tailgate, a state truthful, and/or had a childhood. My connection to them falls into the previous two classes. It wasn’t till I used to be barely an grownup that I first was handed three of those guys at a Jets tailgate within the car parking zone of MetLife Stadium on a grey, bitingly chilly day. The man who handed them to me defined confidently that the right serving measurement was three almost-too-hot Oreos in a single go, and that I needed to eat them now, contemporary out the tiny fryer teetering on the sting of the pick-up truck in the midst of our set-up.

I hated that soccer sport, however I cherished these Oreos. And that man! I married him, like, seven years later.

Each fried Oreo I’ve had since has been so good, regardless of how large a batch or fryer it got here from. For those who’ve additionally obtained good and proper ones, you’ll have smelled them coming earlier than you noticed them. They’re paying homage to funnel cake, with a chewy sweetness that’s so acquainted you’d acknowledge it anyplace. The powdered sugar is in each chunk, but it surely coats that puffy golden shell so effectively you by no means understand how a lot is definitely on there.

And if you happen to’re nonetheless sitting there intrigued (in a great or unhealthy approach!) by the concept that somebody would fry Oreos, that’s by design. This stuff have been mainstays at locations with enjoyable stalls and scrumptious issues for the reason that aughts when a then-teenaged Charlie Boghosian threw a bunch of Oreos in a deep-fryer whereas he was working on the 2001 San Diego County Honest. Why? “To get prospects’ consideration,” he advised Forbes again in 2018. (There are unconfirmed reviews of individuals experimenting and technically “creating” Oreo-frying as early as 1995, however the reputation can firmly be traced again to Boghosian.)

The frequent thread of all fried Oreos, although, is that they really feel like an outside-the-home expertise. This made it an much more enjoyable problem for our workforce to develop this recipe! How might we seize that festive, fair-like vitality (and style and texture) at residence? Our Birmingham check kitchen colleague Melissa Grey recognized a number of variables essential to this experiment: frying temperature, Oreo filling quantity, Oreo temperature, batch measurement, and toppings. Then she examined—and we tasted—batch after batch after batch. 

The primary three variables go hand-in-hand. The upper the oil temp we examined, the crunchier the shell and fewer seen the Oreo filling—each in frozen and non-frozen variations—grew to become. The decrease the temp, the extra unpleasantly melted and soggy the cookies and filling each grew to become. The batter, after all, was additionally typically nonetheless uncooked. Frying Double Stuf Oreos at 375° for 2 minutes was the “candy spot,” Melissa famous, yielding a golden-brown fried exterior, a crunchy cookie, and a lush, vital, intact layer of filling. Yow will discover the total scope of her temperature and filling testing beneath.